The 5167A is exactly what the Aquanaut should be - sporty, legible, and genuinely fun to wear without breaking the bank like a Nautilus would. Movement keeps solid time, the case feels substantial, and it punches way above its price point for a steel sports watch from Patek. Only reason it's not a slam dunk 90+ is that it sits in that awkward middle ground where you're still paying luxury money but not getting the "holy grail" factor, so it really depends on whether you're actually gonna wear it or just collect it.
Affiliate disclosure: Some links on WristRiot are affiliate links. When you make a purchase after clicking one, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site — thank you.